TV Urban Legends Revealed #21
This is the twenty-first in a series of examinations of legends about television and the people involved in TV and whether they are true or false.
Click here to view an archive of the previous TV urban legends.
Let’s begin!
TV LEGEND: An actor’s refusal to take of his wedding ring caused creative filming during the run of the TV series Hogan’s Heroes.
STATUS: True
Hogan’s Heroes was about a group of soldiers during World War II (Americans and other nationalities) who were in for an extended stay in a German prison. However, they still managed to help the war effort from behind bars through various schemes.

One of the prisoners was American Sergeant Andrew J. Carter, played by Larry Hovis.

Carter was a good mimic, so he was always helpful to Colonel Hogan on whatever enterprise he was up to that particular week.
In any event, there was a bit of a problem with how Hovis played Carter. You see, Hovis was married but the character of Carter was single. No problem, right? That’s why they call it acting, no?
The problem was, however, that Hovis refused to take off his wedding ring while filming scenes.
This led to some interesting filming of the series (the directors got their money’s worth out of their film schools, I guess).
Here is an example of how they would try to disguise Hovis’ wedding ring in a scene.
In this episode, Hovis has to impersonate Der Fuehrer to get some important documents out of the camp.
When we first meet him, his left hand is off camera…

Next, his left hand is covered by another actor…

Here, we actually get to see the ring in the background (I circled it, in case you can’t see it)…

Next, Hovis actually just covers up his hand entirely!!

Finally, in full disguise, he is wearing gloves to cover up his hand…

It’s impressive that Hovis was that devoted to the symbol for his marriage, and it’s equally impressive that the show went out of its way to cover up for him.
TV LEGEND: Life Goes On changed their opening credits for the series finale to give some justice to their dog.
STATUS: True
Life Goes On was an ABC hour-long drama that ran from 1989-1993. It was a family drama most noted for its having as a major cast member a character (and actor) with Down’s Syndrome.

The show was often quirky, most notably with its opening theme song, the cast (mostly noted Broadway musical star Patti LuPone, who played the mother on the show) singing the Beatles’ “Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da” while the opening credits show the various cast members waking up in the morning (the show opens with the paper boy delivering the paper).

The recurring joke throughout the opening credits is, as the various family members get ready for the day, the family dog is being ignored.
Here Arnold is waiting to be fed with his dish in his mouth…

A close-up as his frustration continues…

Arnold actually gets a credit in the cast listings…

Finally, as the credits end, we see that no one has fed Arnold, and as he realizes it, he resigns himself to his fate, letting the dish drop out of his mouth…


So it went for four seasons and 82 episodes, and a recurring “complaint” (I’m using the quote because I doubt anyone really cared THAT much) was that Arnold kept getting ignored (and they re-did the opening as the show went on and new cast members came and went, but while other opening gags changed – like Bill Smitrovich, the father, having different reactions as to what to do with his morning fitness routine – Arnold not getting fed stayed the same).
That is, until the 83rd and very LAST episode of the series!
Everything in the credits is the same as normal until we get to the end, where Arnold drops his bowl in frustration, like he always does…

Only THIS time, a bag of dog food falls out of the cabinet and spills on the floor, giving Arnold access to all the dog food he wants!




Isn’t that hilariously awesome?
Well done, Life Goes On producers!
TV LEGEND: Ron Howard was hired for Happy Days based on his performance in American Graffiti.
STATUS: False
People often get caught up in how chronology appears like on the surface.
You can’t even count how many times whatever project comes out first automatically gets the credit for being “first,” and that if something comes out later, it is always perceived as being inspired by the first project, no matter if that is the case or not.
A notable example of this is Ron Howard’s performance in American Graffiti.

The movie, which was set in the very beginning of the 1960s (early enough to effectively be a “50s” movie), came out in 1973 and was a smash hit.
The next year, Howard was the lead in Happy Days, an ABC sitcom set in the 1950s.

So naturally, people assumed that Howard got the Happy Days role (and heck, that the entire reason for Happy Days EXISTING) was because of the success of American Graffiti.
That is, of course, not the case.
Howard appeared as Richie Cunningham in the pilot for a TV sitcom called “New Family In Town”….in 1971!!
The new pilot went unsold, and eventually, in 1972, it aired as an episode of the anthology series Love, American Style (where unsold pilots went to die), titled “Love and the Happy Days”…

However, even before the pilot aired on Love, American Style, George Lucas asked series creator Garry Marshall if he could look at the pilot to see if Howard would work well for the Graffiti role (apparently he did).
So really, it was Graffiti that owed a debt to Happy Days, but then again, the popularity of Graffiti (and the similar success of the Broadway musical, Grease, which was also set in the 1950s) helped get Happy Days started, so I guess the debt is even.
By the by, interestingly enough, due to the three-year break between the first pilot and the second, Howard was now 20 years old, which was obviously a bit of a stretch for a high school sophomore (or were they freshmen in Season 1? They graduated from high school at the end of Season 4, which suggests that they were freshmen in Season 1, but that seems hard to believe, which leads me to think that there was a bit of a time consolidation between Seasons 1 and 2), and he had reservations of taking the role because of his age (also partially because, at age 20, he was already looking forward to a post-acting career).
Okay, that’s it for this week!
Feel free (heck, I implore you!) to write in with your suggestions for future installments! My e-mail address is bcronin@legendsrevealed.com




The Happy Days story wasn’t news to me, but it’s still a great story.
I watched the first season of Life Goes On and sorta liked it, but I grew tired of saccharine-sweet family dramas about halfway through that show’s run, so I didn’t watch the finale. Good to see the dog finally had his day.
I really wish we still had a channel on our cable system that carried Hogan’s Heroes. I used to watch that show all the time, but I completely missed the way they hid Carter’s left hand. I might just have to look up the DVDs.
All in all, a great post, as always, Brian.
Oy.
I can’t believe I actually remember seeing that episode of “Love, American Style” when it first aired!
For “Life Goes On”, don’t you mean the show changed its opening credits? You say that they changed their theme song, but it sounds like the scene was just made different.
So there’s another show besides M*A*S*H that hides one of the actors’ hands? That’ll make watching Hogan episodes a little more fun…
Still, it seems like a lot more effort than it’s worth, when the marital status of Hovis’ character, as I recall, was not particularly relevant.
why not just make the character married, find some sort of tape or whatnot to cover the ring, or just have the character wear gloves all the time? Seems like more practical solutions. Hell the character could even have a compulsion about his hands being covered and lead to “wacky hijinks”.
I believe they wanted him single for possible romantic entanglements.
How about the REAL solution. Take the damned ring off.
Refusing is not ‘devoted to the symbol of marriage’, it is refusing to do the job you are being paid to do.
I was talking with a friend of mine about this recently and he noted how, when he was in the Navy in the 1970s, there were always a couple of guys who refused to take off their wedding rings for any reason. Weird.
Sounds like Rusty’s had a bad marriage…
There were several episodes where Carter was potentially entangled with women (WACS, locals and Gestapo agents), as well as a few letters from a sweetheart back home (who broke his heart by marrying someone else – he almost used their tunnels to go AWOL to go home). So yeah, it was important for Carter to be single.
It may have been a small matter, and I don’t know how his wife felt about it, but it’s admirable that he insisted on wearing his ring.
I don’t consider it admirable that he wouldn’t take the ring off during filming. Seems like he was being a jerk to me, I think they should have just recast the actor. I’m not married, but if I was, and I was an actor playing a single man, I would just take off the ring for filming and make everybody’s work day easier.